Back to Blog
Comparisons 2026-11-11 The Tea & Spice Shoppe 2 views

Plum Sesame Tea vs Long Island Strawberry: Comparison

Plum Sesame Tea vs Long Island Strawberry: Comparison

Compare the distinct flavors of Plum Sesame and Long Island Strawberry teas. One blends black tea with roasted sesame and plum; the other combines Sencha green tea with strawberry and papaya.

Two Distinct Approaches to Flavored Tea

Plum Sesame and Long Island Strawberry are both loose-leaf flavored teas, but they take very different paths to flavor. One is a black tea with roasted sesame and plum bits; the other is a Sencha green tea blended with strawberry and papaya. If you are deciding between them, the choice comes down to whether you want a savory-sweet black tea or a fruit-forward green tea.

Neither is inherently better—they suit different cravings and occasions. Below we break down the key differences so you can pick the one that fits your taste.

Plum Sesame vs Long Island Strawberry at a Glance

  • Base tea: Plum Sesame uses black tea; Long Island Strawberry uses Sencha green tea.
  • Key flavors: Plum Sesame combines plum bits, roasted sesame, and roasted rice for a savory-sweet profile. Long Island Strawberry blends strawberry and papaya with the earthy-floral notes of Sencha.
  • Organic: Long Island Strawberry is labeled organic; Plum Sesame is not labeled organic based on supplied information.
  • Size options: Both are available in 50g and 100g sizes.
  • Price point: Long Island Strawberry has a catalog price of USD 6.21 (compare at USD 9.00). Plum Sesame has a catalog price of USD 6.30 (compare at USD 10.00).

Product Facts

  • Long Island Strawberry, Organic: Long Island Strawberry is a fruit infusion combining Sencha green tea with juicy strawberries and papaya. This explains the bright, fruity flavor and the green tea base, which affects caffeine level and brewing temperature.
    Long Island Strawberry, Organic
    Long Island Strawberry, Organic
  • Plum Sesame "NEW": Plum Sesame contains black tea, plum bits, roasted sesame, roasted rice, cornflower blossoms, and pink cornflower blossoms. The roasted sesame and rice give this tea a savory, toasty character that sets it apart from typical fruit teas.
    Plum Sesame "NEW"
    Plum Sesame "NEW"

Flavor Profile: Savory-Sweet vs Fruity

Plum Sesame brings a unique savory-sweet combination. The black tea provides a robust base, while roasted sesame and roasted rice add nutty, toasty notes. Plum bits contribute a subtle tartness, and cornflower blossoms add a mild floral touch. This tea is closer to a genmaicha-style experience but with plum and sesame instead of matcha.

Long Island Strawberry is purely fruit-forward. Sencha green tea gives it a grassy, slightly earthy undertone, but the dominant flavors are strawberry and papaya. It is sweet, bright, and refreshing—ideal for iced tea or a caffeine-friendly afternoon cup.

Caffeine and Brewing Considerations

Plum Sesame uses black tea, which typically has more caffeine than green tea. Long Island Strawberry uses Sencha green tea, which has moderate caffeine but less than black tea. If you are sensitive to caffeine or prefer a lighter brew, Long Island Strawberry may be the better choice.

Brewing temperature also differs. Green teas like Sencha generally brew best at lower temperatures (around 175°F recommended by many sources, though not provided in the product records), while black tea can handle hotter water (near boiling). Since the supplied information does not include specific brewing instructions, you may need to experiment or follow general guidelines for each base tea type.

Which One Should You Choose?

Choose Plum Sesame if you enjoy savory, toasty flavors and want a tea that pairs well with food or stands alone as a comforting warm cup. It is a good choice if you like genmaicha or hojicha and want something with a fruit twist.

Choose Long Island Strawberry if you prefer bright, sweet fruit flavors and want a tea that works well iced or hot. Its organic label may also be a deciding factor if you prioritize organic ingredients.

Both teas offer distinct experiences, and neither is a substitute for the other. The best pick depends on whether you are in the mood for a savory-sweet black tea or a fruity green tea.

Related Articles

Customer Service
Home
Products
Cart
Profile